There is absolutely no doubt that the Samsung Galaxy S2 is the best phone on the planet right now. It really is as complete as you can expect from any phone currently. Sure, you could perhaps add a better camera to compete directly with the Nokia N8, and a notification LED is a something I always want in a phone. But in the grand scheme of things that is nitpicking, really.

The fact is that the Galaxy will still be one of the best phones in the market six months from now, if not the best. I would even argue that in a year from now it will still be a very competitive phone, hardware wise, and will be able to perfectly run anything you throw at it – the dual core processor and 1 GB of RAM will make sure of that.

But the important thing about the Galaxy, and what the other manufacturers should take note of, is that when you create a phone with the right hardware, when you don’t pull any stops, people will flock around that device. It will be talked about, it will get press, it will get attention regardless of the platform it is running on (whoever said that it is all about the software?); so the next time you manufacturers want to create the new iPhone killer, have a look at the Galaxy S2 and let it inspire your hardware decisions.

I haven’t heard the term ‘ecosystem’ as many times in my whole life as I have since Elop’s announcement on February 11. All of sudden it is all about the ‘ecosystem’, everyone is attributing everything to the ‘ecosystem’ – even when your phone stops working because it got crushed by a bus it apparently has something to do with the ‘ecosystem’ these days.

But you know what? I could not care less about an ‘ecosystem’. Honestly I don’t. And I am getting bored hearing about it everywhere, even more so because everyone seem to take at face value that an ecosystem is the way to go in the future. I have argued before that the concept of an ecosystem doesn’t exists on your PC, so why do I need it on my phone? I don’t need it on my PC, and I don’t want nor need it on my smartphone/mobile computer; the more tied you are an ecosystem the less flexibility and freedom you have to use your phone the way you want to, and if you do not agree with that then just have a look at this – that is a direct consequence of your beloved ‘ecosystem’. And you can be sure that we will see more of that if everyone, manufacturers and consumers alike, is set on jumping on the ‘ecosystem’ bandwagon. (And no, an appstore is not an ‘ecosystem’, appstores existed long before the iPhone no matter how hard Steve Jobs is trying to sell you that they were first, eg. google ‘Handango’ and ‘Palmgear’, both existed years before Apple’s appstore).

I am certain that the future will be about openness, so that you can connect to any cloud that you wish, and the lock-ins that we are see now will seem antiquated. It will about open services and open APIs, and those manufacturers who chose to continue the current path of lock-ins will disappear or be marginalized.

So instead of an ‘ecosystem’ what I want instead is a true mobile computer. I want the full experience in my pocket, with no compromises. I want to be able to carry around my phone and use it just as I would use a laptop. I want access to the whole web, be able to download any file or media and then consume it directly on my phone or my TV, no matter what kind of media it might be.

So who will be the first to throw ‘ecosystem’ in the bin where it belongs and instead focus on what we should be striving for: true mobile computers with complete freedom and unrestricted access to everything in the cloud? That is why I have such high hopes for MeeGo, as I would like to see it as being the stepping stone to something greater and better beyond where everyone are rushing right now.

And if not MeeGo, there is always Canonical of course….

I wrote in another post that I think/hope that the new buzzword ‘ecosystem’ is a just fad that will eventually be replaced by largely platform-independent services and an open OS.

I am aware of that there is little economical incentive for the current big players to go down that path (with Google possibly being the least one to resist as long as it generates traffic for them), something that was also mentioned in the comments of that post. So I have was thinking about it when I came across this article at The Register about Canonical. Since I use Ubuntu it should immediately have occurred to me that Canonical is one of the obvious candidates for coming up with that open solution I am hoping for: if I am not tied to or need nor want any ‘ecosystem’ on my desktop then why would I want it on my smartphone/mobile computer?

In the meanwhile I am crossing my fingers for that rumored MeeGo announcement on June 21!

Sometimes it is good to keep a perspective on how far we have come technology wise in just a few years. Thus, I thought it would be interesting to pitch the best phone currently in existence, the Samsung Galaxy S2, against one of the best and most desirable devices back in 2000, the Palm Pilot Vx, the king of the hill back then, and my first PDA and which ignited my passion for PDAs (which later of course would morph into the smartphones we all know and love).

So let’s rumble!

Samsung Galaxy S2 Palm Pilot Vx
Display Super AMOLED Plus capacitive touchscreen
4.3″
480 x 800 pixels
16M colors
LCD resistive touchscreen

3.2″
160 x 160 pixels
monochrome, 16-grayscale
CPU 1.2 Ghz Dual-core Exynos 20 Mhz Motorola Dragonball
I later overlocked mine to a whopping 28 Mhz!
RAM 1 GB 256 Kb (in the form of heap space where the actual programs ran; RAM memory referred to the storage capacity back then, i.e. what the ROM is today)
ROM 16/32 GB (expandable up to 32 GB) 8 MB
Phone Yes In my wet dreams!
Wifi Wi-Fi 802.11 a/b/g/n Huh?
Bluetooth v. 3.0 Bluewho??
GPS Yes Yeah right pal! Maybe in 2020 if we’re lucky!
Infrared No Yes
Camera 8MP + HD-video recording Why would I want to always carry a camera with me!?
Music playback Yes No
Though there was a hack that allowed you to transfer a mp3 file; I say “a” because with only 8 MB of storage, shared between apps and data…. you do the math! And then of course there was that piezo speaker and no headphone connector.
Oh, and does this count?
Video playback Yes Watching videos on a 160×160 pixel grayscale screen and a 20 Mhz CPU!??
Stop it, you’re killing me!
Browser Yes, including full Flash 10.3 support The closest thing was AvantGo.
I felt so vanguard reading news on my PDA during my daily commute!
Apps Yes Yes
I spent hours and hours playing Bejeweled!
Weight 116 g 114 g
Battery life 1,5 days 3-4 weeks!



To be fair, the comparison would have been slightly different if I would have compared the Samsung to a Psion Revo (which back then I looked long and hard at for a couple of weeks, before finally deciding on the Palm Vx mainly because of the size difference). And then of course there was Microsoft’s Palm PC and the Nokia Communicator.

But the Palm Vx was the sexiest of them all even though it was less capable in many was, but the things it did it did them very well (does that sound familiar??).

And if you wonder what happened to my Palm Vx, as I said above I overclocked it using some hack, and it was hot! And I mean that in a literal sense as well as it would heat up noticeably, but after a couple of months it died on me – the CPU had burned out. But I still keep around here, somewhere….

Nov 142010

I am in the progress of migrating my site from b2evolution to WordPress, which will hopefully be done in a few days.

In the meantime, you can continue reading the “old” site.

© 2011 MobileInfoPlanet Suffusion theme by Sayontan Sinha